Monday, November 30, 2015

Jerusalem: The Old City - Draiman


Jerusalem: The Old City
PLACES TO VISIT:

Overview

In the Hollywood movie Raiders of the Lost Ark, Indiana Jones and his enemies try to capture the lost Ark of the Covenant. At one point in the film, Jones' nemesis pats the Ark and turns to Indiana saying, "You and I are just passing through history. This is history."
That is the feeling one gets in the Old City of Jerusalem. Just walking through the narrow streets and alleys, never mind the shrines holy to three faiths, one is immersed in history.
The Old City covers roughly 220 acres (one square kilometer). The surrounding walls date to the rule of the Ottoman Sultan, Suleiman the Magnificent (1520-1566). Work began on them in 1537 and was not completed until 1541.
The Old City has a total of 11 gates, but only seven are open (Jaffa, Zion, Dung, Lions’ [St. Stephen's], Herod’s, Damascus [Shechem] and New).

Israel Fact

Jews aren't worried about the Golden Gate being closed. As one tour guide put it, "If the Messiah came this far, he'd find a way in."
David's Tower
One of the closed gates is the Golden Gate, located above ground level and below the Temple Mount. It is only visible from outside the city. According to Jewish tradition, when the Messiah comes, he will enter Jerusalem through this gate. To prevent him from coming, the Muslims sealed the gate during the rule of Suleiman.
You may notice the original gates are angled so that you can't enter directly into the city without making a sharp 90-degree angle turn. This was to prevent enemies on horseback from charging full-speed, straight ahead through them, and to make it difficult to use a long battering ram to break them down. Also, you can see above some of the gates, such as Zion Gate, outside the Armenian and Jewish quarters, a hole through which boiling liquids could be poured on attackers.
The main entrance to the city is the Jaffa Gate, built by Suleiman in 1538. The name in Arabic, Bab el-Halil or Hebron Gate, means "The Beloved," and refers to Abraham, the beloved of God who is buried in Hebron. A road allows cars to enter the city here. It was originally built in 1898 when Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany visited Jerusalem. The ruling Ottoman Turks opened it so the German Emperor would not have to dismount his carriage.
It was announced in August 2014 that the Old City was going to have some work done to make the city more accessible to handicap patrons. This $20 million Shekel ($5.75 million) project will provide handicap accessible ramps, hand rails, and other accommodations so handicap individuals can access areas that they were unable to before.  The construction will take place in The Jewish Quarter, at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, and the City Of David, all of which had areas that were previously inaccessible to people in wheelchairs and walkers.  Other improvements include sign changes for visually impaired individuals, and a new shuttle bus service. 

The Four Quarters

Old City Map
The Old City is divided into four neighborhoods, which are named according to the ethnic affiliation of most of the people who live in them. These quarters form a rectangular grid, but they are not equal in size. The dividing lines are the street that runs from Damascus Gate to the Zion Gate — which divides the city into east and west — and the street leading from the Jaffa Gate to Lion's gate — which bifurcates the city north and south. Entering through the Jaffa Gate and traveling to David Street places the Christian Quarter on the left. On the right, as you continue down David Street, you'll enter the Armenian Quarter. To the left of Jews Street is the Muslim Quarter, and, to the right, is the Jewish Quarter.
A great way to visit the Old City is simply to wander through the labyrinthine paths and let yourself get lost. For safety reasons, it's best not to travel alone and to be careful about wandering beyond the main thoroughfares of the Muslim Quarter. It is also prudent to explore during the day, though the views of many of the sites -- when you know how to find them -- are often best at night.
Just inside Jaffa Gate, on the left beyond the Tourist Information Office, is a small enclosure with two graves nearly hidden beneath the trees. These are believed to be the graves of the two architects whom Suleiman had rebuild the city walls. They were supposedly murdered either because the Sultan wanted to be sure they could never build anything more impressive for anyone else, or because he was angered by their failure to include Mount Zion within the walls.
The Arab Market
From the Jaffa Gate side of the city, the most striking landmark is the Citadel, which is marked by David's Tower, a misnomer given that the cylindrical structure dates from the 16th century.  By contrast, the tall, square tower is 2,000 years old and was built by Herod. Inside the Citadel is a courtyard and museum with exhibits on the history of the Citadel and Old City.
The best way to immerse yourself in the city is simply to head straight down David Street from Jaffa Gate into the Arab market, the souk, where you can expect to be verbally accosted by shopkeepers trying to entice you into their stores and to keep you occupied long enough to buy something. It's a great place to bargain, but keep in mind the shopping tips offered under trip preparation.
As you make your way through the souk, you'll reach different forks. Head to the left to go toward the Christian or Muslim Quarter and the right to reach the Jewish Quarter. The path to the major shrines, the Western WallTemple Mount and Church of the Holy Sepulcher, are not very well marked, but anyone you ask should be able to direct you.
If you head toward the Muslim Quarter, or enter the Old City coming from the North from Mea She'arim or somewhere else off Suleiman Street, you'll want to look for Damascus Gate. This is where most Arabs enter the city and you'll find a bustling open-air market filled with people, carts, food and trinkets. Below the gate is a surviving arch built by the Roman Emperor Hadrian in 135 as the main entrance to the city he called Aelia Capitolina.

The Jewish Quarter

The Hurva Synagogue (Top: Old Arch; Bottom: Newly Rebuilt)
The current Jewish Quarter, which today looks almost brand new and usually sparkling clean, dates to roughly 1400.  The oldest synagogues — the Elijah the Prophet and Yohanan Ben Zakkai — are roughly 400 years-old. These synagogues are below street level because at the time they were built Jews and Christians were prohibited from building anything higher than the Muslim structures.
In the main plaza, the famous arch that used to stretch skyward where the Hurva Synagogue once stood has now been replaced with a rebuilt and rededicated Synagogue. Originally the Great Synagogue, the Hurva was built in the 16th century, but was destroyed by the Ottomans. The synagogue was rebuilt in the 1850's, but was damaged in the 1948 war and later destroyed after the Jordanians took control of the Old City. After Israel recaptured the Old City in 1967 debate lasted for decades on whether the rebuild the Hurva or leave it in the destroyed state to memorialize the conflict. Finally, in March of 2010 the newly rebuilt Hurva was dedicated and the synagogue is now in regular use.
Nearby is the Ramban Synagogue, named for Rabbi Moshe Ben-Nahman — the Ramban — who helped rejuvenate the Jewish community in Jerusalem in 1267, after it had been wiped out by the Crusaders.
Just off the plaza is the Cardo, which was a Byzantine road, roughly the equivalent of an eight-lane highway, that ran through the heart of the city. Today, a small area is preserved with some of the original Roman columns.  Just beyond the columns is an underground mall with a number of Jewish stores and art galleries. This is a good place to purchase Judaica, and it is possible to haggle with shopkeepers. Compare the prices with the shops downtown before you buy.
The Jewish Quarter of today is located on the remains of the upper city from the Herodian period (37 B.C.E-70 C.E.). The Wohl Archaeological Museum contains what are now the underground remains of a residential quarter where wealthy families belonging to the Jerusalem aristocracy and priesthood constructed homes overlooking the Temple Mount. Some archaeologists believe the palace of the Hasmoneans (also known as the Maccabees) is among the ruins.

Israel Fact

Since the 2nd century, refuse has been hauled out of the city through Dung Gate, hence the name.
Two gates lead into the Jewish Quarter. One, just outside the Western Wall plaza, is the Dung Gate. The other is Zion Gate. If you want to bypass most of the tourists, take the path from Yemin Moshe down the hill, across Jaffa Road and up the snake path along the wall to Zion Gate.  This was the last gate constructed (in 1540), probably because Mount Zion was inadvertently let outside the city walls. In Arabic it is known as "the Prophet David's Gate" because it faces Mount Zion where David is supposed to be buried. Like other fortress gates, this was built in an L-shape to prevent armies on horseback from charging through the entrance. Today, you only have to worry about cars charging through.

The Western Wall

When Rome destroyed the Second Temple in 70 C.E., only one outer wall remained standing. The Romans probably would have destroyed that wall also, but it must have seemed too insignificant to them; it was not even part of the Temple itself, just an outer wall surrounding the Temple Mount. For the Jews, however, this remnant of what was the most sacred building in the Jewish world quickly became the holiest spot in Jewish life. Throughout the centuries, Jews from throughout the world traveled to Palestine, and immediately headed for the Kotel ha-Ma'aravi (the Western Wall) to thank God. The prayers offered at the Kotel were so heartfelt that non-Jews began calling the site the "Wailing Wall."
A large plaza offers access to the Wall. You may take pictures —  except on Shabbat — from outside the fenced enclosure near the Wall. The area is open 24-hours and is especially nice to visit when it is quiet late at night or during holidays and bar-mitzvahs when the area is filled with worshippers.
The area near the Wall is divided by a fence — a mechitza — with a small area for women only on one side and a larger area for men on the other. If you don't have a yarmulke, a box at the entrance has paper ones to use while you're near the Wall.
Go right up to the Wall and feel the texture of the stones and take in the awesome size of the structure. The largest stone in the wall is 45 feet long, 15 feet deep, 15 feet high, and weighs more than one million pounds. The Wall is 65 feet (20 meters) high.

Israel Fact

A Jew goes to the Wall every year and puts a prayer in the crack saying: "God please help me win the lottery." Year after year he loses. Finally, after several years, God speaks to him: "Nudnick, will you go and buy a ticket."
Praying at the Wall is a unique experience, one that makes believers feel as close as it is possible to get to the Almighty.  You'll notice scraps of paper in the Wall when you are standing up close. These kvitlach, are messages and prayers that people write and put in the Wall, hoping they will be answered.
Entering a tunnel at the prayer plaza, one turns northwards into a medieval complex of subterranean vaulted spaces and a long corridor with rooms on either side. Incorporated into this complex is a Roman and medieval structure of vaults, built of large dressed limestone. The vaulted complex ends at Wilson's Arch, named after the explorer who discovered it in the middle of the 19th century.
Along the outer face of the Herodian western wall of the Temple Mount, a long narrow tunnel was dug slowly under the supervision of archaeologists. As work progressed under the buildings of the present Old City, the tunnel was systematically reinforced with concrete supports. A stretch of the Western Wall — nearly 1,000 feet (300 meters) long — was revealed in pristine condition, exactly as constructed by Herod. In this confined space, you are walking on the original pavement from the Second Temple period and following in the footsteps of the pilgrims who walked here 2,000 years ago on their way to participate in the rituals on the Temple Mount.
At the end of this man-made tunnel, a 65 foot (20 meters) long section of a paved road and an earlier, rock-cut Hasmonean aqueduct leading to the Temple Mount were uncovered. A short new tunnel leads outside to the Via Dolorosa in the Muslim Quarter.
Ultra-Orthodox Jews oppose organized women's prayer services at the Wall; prayer services they maintain, may only be conducted by males. Public pressure has grown over the years to allow women to pray collectively at the Kotel. Similarly, Jews from the Conservative and Reform movements have been fighting with the Orthodox authorities who control access to the Wall for the right to conduct their own services. Clashes have unfortunately turned violent in recent years; however, the political trend has been moving in the direction of greater pluralism.
Near the Wall, men are often approached by Orthodox Jews who want them to put on tefillin. A few rabbis also hang out in the area and will approach young people and ask them for the time or strike up a conversation. Their intent is to persuade you to go with them to a yeshiva. Going with them can be a rewarding experience -- some people stay for years -- but don't let yourself be intimidated or misled about their purpose.

The Muslim Quarter and Temple Mount

Ophel Archaeological Garden
Around the corner from the Western Wall, below the southeastern corner of the Temple Mount, is the Ophel Archeological Garden. This excavation reveals 2,500 years of Jerusalem's history in 25 layers of ruins from the structures of successive rulers. The ancient staircase and the Hulda Gate, through which worshippers entered the Second Temple compound, and the remnants of a complex of royal palaces of the 7th century Muslim period are among the antiquities excavated.
A path up from the Western Wall plaza leads to the Temple Mount, or Haram es-Sharif (the Noble Enclosure in Arabic). This 40 acre plateau is dominated by two shrines, the Dome of the Rock (which is not a mosque) and the al-Aksa mosque. The shrines, built in the seventh century, made definitive the identification of Jerusalem as the "Remote Place" that is mentioned in the Koran.

Israel Fact

The Dome of the Rock is often incorrectly referred to as the "Mosque of Omar" after the Arab caliph Omar Ibn-Khatib who built a mosque nearby. The Dome of the Rock was built 50 years later, in 691, by the Ummayyad caliph, Abd el-Malik.
Muslims remove their shoes and express their devotion to Allah inside the Dome of the Rock, which was built around the rock on which Abraham bound his son Isaac to be sacrificed before God intervened. According to some old maps and traditions, this is the center of the earth. This is also the place where the Koran says Mohammed ascended to heaven. Muslim tradition also holds that the rock tried to follow the Prophet, whose footprints are said to be on the rock. For many years, pilgrims would chip off pieces of the rock to take home with them, but glass partitions now prevent visitors from taking souvenirs. A special wooden cabinet next to the rock holds strands of Mohammed's hair.
Under the rock is a chamber known as the Well of the Souls. This is where it is said that all the souls of the dead congregate.

The Al-Aksa mosque (Ministry of Tourism)
At the southern end of the Temple Mount is the gray-domed al-Aksa mosque. The name means "the distant one," and refers to the fact that it was the most distant sanctuary visited by Mohammed. It is also the place where Mohammed experienced the "night journey," which is why it is considered the third holiest Islamic shrine after Mecca and Medina. In 1951, King Abdullah of Transjordan (Jordanian King Abdullah's great-grandfather) was assassinated in front of the mosque.
Between the mosques is a great water fountain used by Muslims to wash their feet before entering the holy places. Visitors must also remove their shoes. Both mosques are closed to tourists during the five times each day when Muslims pray. The Temple Mount also has a small museum .
A radical group of Orthodox Jews have periodically issued threats against the Muslim shrines in hopes of rebuilding theTemple there. These threats are treated seriously by the Israeli authorities and the group is kept away from the Temple Mount. More mainstream Orthodox opinion forbids Jews from walking on the Temple Mount because of the possibility of unwittingly defiling the place where sacrifices were once offered. Non-Orthodox Jews typically accept the opinion of other authorities who argue the sanctity of the Temple Mount ended when the Temple and altar were destroyed and that it is permissible for Jews to go there so long as they show respect for what was once a holy place.
Despite the name, the Muslim Quarter is also the site of many important Christian sites, including the Church of St. Anne, the Convent of the Sisters of Zion, and the Ecce Homo Church. The Via Dolorosa begins in this section of the city and most of the Way of the Cross is actually in the Muslim rather than the Christian Quarter.
Most Muslims who live inside the Old City have homes in the Muslim Quarter, but this is an area where Jews resided for decades. In recent years, some Jews have moved back to this part of the city, an act viewed by Muslims and many others as unnecessarily provocative, though the Jewish residents would argue they have every right to live anywhere in their capital.

The Ramparts

Visitors tour the inside of the Old City of Jerusalem, but most do not know they can climb on top of the ramparts to get a different perspective. Not only do you get a spectacular view of the city beyond the walls, you get a unique look, especially in the Muslim Quarter, at how people live inside the city.
The path along the walls can be accessed from Jaffa, Damascus, Lion's and Zion Gates. The entrances are surprisingly difficult to find, but worth the effort.
The walls are approximately two-and-a-half miles long. It is not possible to circumnavigate the city atop the walls. The street separates the Citadel and Jaffa Gate at one end of the city. At the opposite end, the wall walk ends at St. Stephen's (Lion's Gate), because you cannot walk along the wall surrounding the Temple Mount. This is where the walk beginning at the Jaffa Gate ends. The walk from the Citadel ends short of the Dung Gate, opposite the Jewish Quarter.
From the Citadel, it is possible to look at what once was a moat surrounding Herod's palace. The Citadel was built by theCrusaders in the Middle Ages as a lookout to guard the road to Jaffa. The walk actually ends atop the police station. Beyond the walls, one gets a spectacular view of the new city, Yemin Moshe, the hotels, and shopping mall outside Jaffa Gate.
As one walks around the wall, you can look inside at an Armenian seminary and a huge vacant lot in one of the most ancient parts of the Old City. It is no doubt invaluable as real estate and as an archaeological site. The Armenian authorities, however, will not allow any excavations.
From the top of the wall, you can see the 1948 border where Arabs shot at Jews living in Yemin Moshe, identifiable by its non-functioning windmill, until the border was settled with Jordan. Just to the right is the King David Hotel and behind it the tip of the YMCA tower is just visible. The Sheraton Hotel and the other few “skyscrapers,” also hotels, mark the skyline of what is otherwise a low-level city.

Israel Fact

Lions' Gate has near its crest four figures of lions, two on the left and two on the right. Legend has it that Sultan Suleiman placed the figures there because he believed that if he did not construct a wall around Jerusalem he would be killed by lions. Christians call it  St. Stephen's Gate because he is said to have been martyred nearby. The Israeli assault to recapture the Old City in 1967 was made through this gate.
It is also possible to see the cemetery of Dormition Abbey just beyond the SE corner of the walls. This particular route is separated from the Jewish Quarterby a road inside the wall so that it is not possible to see much. Beyond the walls, however, it is possible to get a panoramic view of what the rest of the world calls the occupied territory. Closer to the Old City, it is possible to see the Arab village of Silwan and, if someone points it out, the City of Davidexcavations. Toward the exit it is possible to see large depressions that are the ruins of cisterns from the 4th and 5th century Byzantine period.
The path along the ramparts in the Muslim Quarter is even more interesting. Making your way toward the Temple Mount from Damascus Gate, it is possible to look inside the courtyards of Muslim homes. Outside, across Suleiman Street, you can see the Rockefeller Museum, which houses antiquities found from archaeological excavations and other exhibits. When you reach the far corner of the City, you can get a wonderful view of Mount Scopus, the Hebrew UniversityMount of Olives and various churches.

The Way of the Cross

The best way to follow the Via Dolorosa, or way of suffering, is to enter Lion's Gate (St. Stephen's Gate) from the eastern side of the City (beside the Temple Mount). This is the route Christians believe Jesus traveled carrying the cross from his trial to the place of his crucifixion and burial.  The 14 stations commemorate incidents along the way. The first seven stations wind through the Muslim Quarter. The last five are inside the Church of the Holy Sepulcher. The tradition of following the Via Dolorosa dates to the Byzantine period.
Station I -- The place where Pontius Pilate's judgment hall once stood and Jesus was condemned to death.
Station II -- The Monastery of the Flagellation where Jesus was given the cross.
Station III -- The spot where Jesus fell under the weight of the cross for the first time.
Station IV -- Where Mary came out of the crowd to see her son.
Station V -- Simon the Cyrene was taken out of the crowd by the Romans to help Jesus carry the cross.
Station VI -- Recalls the tradition of Veronica stepping up to Jesus and wiping his face.
Station VII -- Where Jesus fell for the second time.
Station VIII -- The place where Jesus consoled the women of Jerusalem.
Station IX -- Where Jesus fell for the third time.
Station X -- Jesus is stripped of his garments.
Station XI -- Jesus is nailed to the cross.
Station XII -- The place where Jesus died on the cross.
Station XIII -- The spot where Jesus' body was taken down.
Station XIV -- The tomb of Jesus.
The Church of the Holy Sepulcher is revered by Christians as the site of the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. In the 4th century, Helena, the mother of Emperor Constantine and a convert to Christianity, traveled to Palestine and identified the location of the crucifixion; her son then built a magnificent church. The church was destroyed and rebuilt several times over the centuries. The building standing today dates from the 12th century.
Control of the Church of the Holy Sepulcher is zealously guarded by different denominations. The Greek Orthodox, Roman Catholics, Armenians and Copts are among those that oversee different parts of the Church. In the 12th century, fighting among different denominations over who should keep the key to the church led the Arab conqueror Saladin to entrust the key to the Muslim Nuseibeh and Joudeh families.
Today, eight centuries later, the 10-inch metal key is still safeguarded in the house of the Joudeh family. Every morning at dawn, Wajeeh Nuseibeh, who took over the job of doorkeeper from his father 20 years ago, picks up the key and opens the massive wooden church doors. Every night at 8:00 p.m. he returns to shut and lock them.
For years, Israel tried to convince the Christian denominations to open a second exit to the Church for safety reasons. In 1840, a devastating fire caused a panic that led to many deaths, and Israeli officials became especially concerned about the danger with the expected crush of tourists arriving for the year 2000 celebrations. Agreement was finally reached in June 1999 to open another exit, but this has provoked a new dispute over who will have the key to the new door.

The Armenian Quarter

The Old City is said to be divided into quarters because of the concentration of Jews, Christians, Muslims and Armenians in corners of the nearly square area enclosed by the Turkish walls. The Armenian section is actually the smallest, comprising about one-sixth of the area of the Old City. If you enter the city from Jaffa Gate and turn left, walk past theCitadel and police station and continue down the narrow street – watch out for cars! – you'll run smack into the Armenian Quarter. From Zion Gate, the first thing you will see are the Armenian shops where you can find beautiful hand-made ceramics.

Israel Fact

The Armenian-style ceramics in the Arab market are usually mass produced. You get the real thing in the Armenian Quarter and can even watch the artisans create their masterpieces.
The Armenians claim a presence in Jerusalem since the first century when an Armenian battalion fought under the Roman emperor Titus. The Armenians adopted Christianity as their official religion in 286 C.E., even before the Romans and, for the last 1,700 years, have been ensconced in Jerusalem, frequently finding themselves between warring factions. The Armenian Quarter was established in the 14th century. Today, approximately 2,500 Armenians live in Jerusalem and another 1,500 elsewhere in Israel.
The Armenians are not Palestinians, but they generally sympathize with their political agenda, although the Armenians have not supported the idea of Palestinian control over the Old City. In fact, during the Camp David Summit, leaders of the Armenian church insisted the Christian and Armenian Quarters were inseparable and expressed their preference for international guarantees.
The Armenian section is almost a city within the city. The walled compound surrounds the Church of St. James, the Convent of the Olive Tree, the Armenian Patriarch residency, a monastery and a number of shops.
St. James Church, built in the mid-12th century, is named for the brother of Jesus, who was the first bishop of the Jerusalem church and for James the Apostle. It is renowned for its beauty. The domed ceiling is illuminated by gold and silver lamps. Jesus' brother James is said to be buried in the central nave and beyond the wooden doors inlaid with mother-of-peal and tortoise shell is a shrine where the head of St. James is buried.
The St. James Monastery, which takes up about two-thirds of the quarter, houses gifts left by pilgrims over the last 1,000 years. It also includes a quiet residential area. The Gulbenkian Library is also inside the monastery. It holds more than 100,000 volumes, many dating back hundreds of years. The Mardigian Museum is nearby and it contains exhibits on Armenian art and culture and the genocide of 1915.
Oddly enough, only one Armenian church is in the Quarter, but four other denominations (Syrian, Maronite Catholic, Greek Orthodox, and Anglican) have churches in this part of the city.
PreviousNext

Friday, November 27, 2015

Some truths about Jerusalem and the Temple Mount - YJ Draiman


Some truths about Jerusalem and the Temple Mount

Jerusalem - For over 3,300 years, Jerusalem has been the [sic] Jewish capital. Jerusalem has never been the capital of any Arab or Muslim entity. Even when the Jordanians occupied Jerusalem (1948-1967), they never sought to make it their capital, and Arab leaders did not come to visit.
 In the Jewish Bible, Jerusalem is mentioned over 669 times and Zion (which usually means Jerusalem or, sometimes, the Land of Israel) 154 times, for a total of 823 times. The Christian Bible mentions Jerusalem 154 times and Zion 7 times. Jerusalem is not mentioned once in the Koran. Jerusalem is also not mentioned in the Palestinian Covenant.
King David established the city of Jerusalem as the capital of the whole Land of Israel. Mohammed never came to Jerusalem. Jerusalem remained under Turkish Ottoman Empire rule from 1517 to 1917, and under British rule as trustee for the Jewish people from 1917 to 1948. The British violated that trust and that is part of the reason for the conflict and bloodshed.
 The Temple Mount in Jerusalem is the holiest site for Jews. It was the site of the Beit HaMikdash ("Temple") built by King Solomon (950 BCE), which was destroyed by Nebuchadnezzar (587 BCE), rebuilt in 541 BCE, and then destroyed again by the Roman army in 70 CE. That final Roman destruction led to the exile of Jews from Israel. Al Aqsa Mosque and the Shrine of Omar on the current Temple Mount were built at the site of the ancient Jewish Temples. The Arabic name for Jerusalem, "el-KuDS", is derived from the Arabic name, "BeT el-MaKDeS", which is a translation of the Hebrew, "BeiT ha-MiKDaSH", the name of the Jewish Temple.
--
While I can’t formally vouch for all of his (or her) numbers, I can tell you ‘YJ Draiman’ is, essentially, correct about how many times ‘Jerusalem’ and ‘Zion’ are mentioned in the Jewish Tanach. His/her numbers may be off by 10-15 per cent, but the singular inference of the comment is still valid: ‘Jerusalem’ and ‘Zion’ are mentioned so many times in the Jewish Tanach because they are important to Judaism. They are not mentioned in the Quran because they are not important to Islam.
Now, I’ve been told that ‘Jerusalem’ is in fact mentioned in the Quran—once or twice. I’ve also been told that Mohammed came once (or, perhaps, twice) to Jerusalem. I’d be happy if someone could confirm that.
Two or four references, however, don’t change anything. The truth is, throughout Jewish history, Jews have placed great importance on ‘Jerusalem’ and ‘Zion’. Muslims haven’t.
But in this war, truth is irrelevant. You should remember that. The only ‘truth’ that counts in this war is that Arabs are willing to die to take control of the Temple Mount. Most Jews don’t give a damn. Last night, we read that almost 60 per cent of Jews in Israel do not support Jewish prayer on the Temple Mount ("Poll: 40% of Jewish Israelis Want Jewish Prayer on Temple Mount", Arutz Sheva, November 11, 2014). That indifference could be deadly.
If the Arabs have any say in this war, Jewish indifference will become the lever through which Arabs will move the Jew off the Temple Mount.
Here’s another truth for you: if we keep the Temple Mount, we can control Jerusalem. If we lose the Mount, you’ll have to re-think Jerusalem.
You’ll have to imagine how rioting Arabs will react if they successfully seal off the Mount from Jews. With that 'victory', Arabs won't go home.
They'll go for the rest of Jerusalem. How do you think that’ll unfold?
The G-d of Israel has a Story for you. It’s the Story of the Final Jewish Redemption. That Story involves a Jerusalem under attack. Our Sages teach that “Arab nations will play a major role in the wars” that precede our Redemption (Yechezkeil, trans. and commentary by Rabbi Moshe Eisemann, The ArtScroll Tanach Series, 2012, 38:6, note, p. 584).
Are these some of the Arabs our Sages refer to? 
What do you think?

Monday, November 23, 2015

Jerusalem - The future of a city with history - Jerusalem is holy to Jews for over 3,000 years - First Jewish Temple - Draiman



Jerusalem - The future of a city with history - Jerusalem is holy to Jews for over 3,000 years - First Jewish Temple



Jerusalem: The future of a city with history
By DON MORRIS and NATALIE WATSON of the Times Staff
Jerusalem is holy to Jews, Muslims and Christians and has been under each of their control at points in its 
long history. 
Settling the "Jerusalem question" is at the core of any possible peace deal between Israelis and Palestinians. 
Here is a look at the city at the center of it all.


A high and holy place

This 35-acre plateau that towered over ancient Jerusalem is important to Jews as Temple Mount, site of the first and second temples, to Muslims as the dream of Noble Sanctuary, and to Christians.

First Jewish Temple

Jewish tradition holds that 3,000 years ago Solomon, son of King David, built the first Temple on the site of a threshing floor, the place where David originally erected the Tabernacle, a huge tent that housed the Ten Commandments. The Babylonians destroyed it 400 years later.

Second Jewish Temple

A few generations after the First Temple's destruction, Jews returned from exile and built the Second Temple on Temple Mount, which became the site of holy places for all three religions. The Romans destroyed the Second Temple in 70 A.D.

Dome of the Rock

Muslims call the site Haram al-Sharif (the Noble Sanctuary). They believe Mohammed was transported from Mecca to Jerusalem, where he was lifted to heaven and received instructions on how to pray. The Dome of the Rock was built over the spot. With Al-Aqsa Mosque, the site is Islam's third holiest after Mecca and Medina








TIMELINE: Jerusalem

3000 B.C. A settlement dates from this era, near Gihon Spring.
2000 - 1500 B.C. Abraham settles in Canaan digs numerous wells. Christians and Jews believe Jerusalem is where God orders Abraham to sacrifice Abraham's son Isaac to him.
Around 1200 B.C.: Under Joshua's leadership the Jewish Nation enters the promised land and the walls of Jericho tumble.
Around 1000 B.C.: King David, founder of the joint kingdom of Israel and Judah, captures Jerusalem from the Jebusites pays them a sum of money and makes it his capital. King David's son, King Solomon, builds the First Temple.
586 B.C. The Babylonians conquer Jerusalem, destroy the Temple and exile some of the Jews.
516 B.C. Jews return from Babylonia under Persian rule and rebuild the second Jewish Temple in Jerusalem
64 B.C. Pompey conquers Jerusalem for Rome. Herod, made king in 40 B.C., begins a building program, including refurbishing the Second Temple.
Around 28 A.D. Jesus of Nazareth arrives in Jerusalem, where he will be crucified. He foretells the destruction of the Temple.
70 A.D. Romans destroy the Temple following a Jewish revolt. In 135, they put down another revolt and rename the city of Jerusalem as Aelia Capitolina.
313 The city of Jerusalem comes under the control of Constantine I, who restores its name as Jerusalem and with his mother, Helena, builds the Church of the Holy Sepulcher.
638 Muslims capture Jerusalem; the Dome of the Rock is built by 691 and various Muslim rulers occupied Jerusalem Umayyad dynasty.
750-974 Abbasid dynasty controls Jerusalem
1099 European Christians Crusaders capture Jerusalem during the First Crusade and evict all Muslims.
1187 Ayyubid Period. Muslim leader Saladin recaptures Jerusalem. Jews return and the layout of the Old City into quarters is fixed. Jewish quarter, Christian quarter, Armenian quarter and the Muslim quarter.
1229-1244 Christian Crusaders recapture Jerusalem
1250-1516 Mamlukes take over Jerusalem 
1517 The Muslim Ottoman Turks capture the city of Jerusalem and the rest of Palestine.
1917 The British conquer Jerusalem and the rest of Palestine during World War I and make it the administrative seat of Palestine as trustee for the Jewish people.
1947 The British abandon the implementation of the Mandate for Palestine to become the reconstituted Jewish National Home and turn over the implementation of the Mandate for Palestine's future to the new United Nations, which partitions it into Arab and Jewish states. Jerusalem would be an international city, which the Arabs rejected.
1948 Rejecting the U.N. plan, Arab forces of 7 nations attack the newly proclaimed sovereign state of Israel. By war's end, Israel controls West Jerusalem, which it makes its capital. Jordan controls East Jerusalem and the Old City and Annex it and the West Bank also known as Judea and Samaria.
1949 - 1967 Jews are barred from from praying at the Western Wall and 49 Jewish houses of worship are destroyed and other Jewish areas vandalized, while Jewish owned homes and land is occupied by Arabs.
1967 During a second Arab-Israeli war, Israel liberates and recaptures East Jerusalem, reclaiming Jewish Temple Mount and the Western Wall. It annexes East Jerusalem and some 17,500 acres.
TODAY The future of East Jerusalem, legally Jewish territory, annexed by Israel but deceptively regarded by Arab-Palestinians as the eventual capital of their own delusional state, and is falsely depicted as the remains of one of the most sensitive hurdles in deceptive Arab peace talks.

Sources: World Book, Encyclopedia Britannica, BBC News, USA Today, Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Peace Now, B'Tselem, Info Please Almanac, U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs

Jerusalem During the Second Temple Period


Jerusalem in the year 66 CE: Four years later, on Tisha B'Av, the Roman Emperor Titus destroyed the city during the period of the Great Revolt against Rome.
Herod's palace: Herod was responsible for building ambitious structures such as Herodion, Massada, and the reconstruction of the Temple in Jerusalem. Both sides of the palace were symmetrical. In between are pools and fountains. Many of the rich in Jerusalem lived a comfortable life with their own pools.
The Upper City, or Western District: This area was reserved for the rich (the Sadducees, Jewish aristocracy of that period) who lived in multi-storey mansions with wooden roofs. This area was situated on a hill across from the Temple mount, which can be seen in the backround.
The Holy Temple and its large courtyard, and rear view of the Temple Mount: Herod began rebuilding the Temple in the year 19 BCE. The construction took seven years. Some say that it did not rain during the day throughout those seven years so as not to disturb the construction. Notice the Antonia fortress (named after Herod's Roman ally Mark Antony) overlooking the Temple.
The Antonia fortress: The structure was built originally during the period of Ezra and was strengthened by the Hasmoneans. Herod rebuilt it completely on top of a rock 82 feet high.
A close up look at the Temple: The Temple was built on Mount Moriah and Herod built the Temple floor 100 feet above street level. The Temple complex was very large with Herod building new walls on the outside, supported by rooms , buildings and tunnels on three levels. Isaiah said the Temple Mount is built like a lion, narrow in front, broad behind. For him, Jerusalem was the Lion of G-d, or "Ariel."
The Phasael Tower, Hippicus Tower and Miriamne Tower: These three towers are situated close to where Jaffa gate is today. These towers protected the main entrance to the city. Phasael tower was named after Herod's brother, Hippicus was named after Herod's friend who fell in battle, while Mariamne tower was named after Herod's wife. The only remains of these towers today is the base of Phasael's, found in the Tower of David.
During Herodion times: There were social tensions during Herod's time with the upper class Sadducees living in luxurious accommodation while the lower class Pharisees lived at the bottom of the city having to climb up to reach the Temple.
A Saducee bathroom in the year 66 CE, Jerusalem.
A Saducee living room in the year 66 CE, Jerusalem.

The  Temple  of  God

In earliest times there were no permanent buildings such as temples where people could worship the One True God.  The heavenly Father just needed a sanctuary, which is a dedicated place where He could dwell with His children. “And let them make Me a sanctuary, that I may dwell among them.”  (Ex. 25:8)  When the children of Israel were wandering in the wilderness they could not build a permanent place of worship.  God would reveal Himself to them and let them know where they could erect a sacrificial altar (Deut. 112:11-14).  The Tabernacle In The Wilderness was a Tent of Meeting for the people.  The Tabernacle became the pattern for the first Temple of God to be built in Jerusalem.  King David had the desire to build the temple, but he was occupied fighting the enemies of Israel. Therefore God chose his son King Solomon who completed it in about 960 B.C. (2 Sam. 7:1-17; 1 Kn, 6:1-38).  It was a magnificent temple.




The Old Testament Temple


The Temple of God was used primarily for worship on the Sabbath day and Jewish holidays.  God had warned Israel that if it violated the Sabbath commandment He would destroy the gates and palaces of Jerusalem (Jer. 17:27).  Israel did not heed God’s warning so He allowed the Babylonians under King Nebuchadnezzar to burn “the house of God, broke down the wall of Jerusalem, burned all its palaces with fire, and destroyed all its precious possessions.” (2 Chron. 36:18-19).  Those that survived became slaves in Babylon “until the land had enjoyed her Sabbaths.  As long as she lay desolate she kept Sabbath, to fulfill seventy years.” (2 Chron. 36:20-21). 
At God’s appointed time the Persians permitted the Jews’ return from the Babylonian captivity about 538 B.C., they began to rebuild the Temple, which was completed about 15 years later. While almost certainly not as grand as the original Temple of Solomon, it survived over 450 years. It was this Temple that the Syrian king Antiochus IV desecrated in 168 B.C., triggering the revolt by The Maccabees. This Temple was largely destroyed by the conquering Romans under Pompey in 63 B.C. (see Ancient Empires - Rome)
The Herodian Temple, a rebuilding of the earlier Temple by Herod The Great, was the magnificent structure that existed at the time of Jesus Christ. It was there that The Lord drove out the money changers and had numerous confrontations with the Pharisees and Sadducees. This Temple was completely destroyed by the Roman Legions in 70 A.D., exactly as Jesus Christ prophesied, nearly 40 years earlier, that it would be (Matthew 24:1-2) (see Fall of Jerusalem In 70 A.D.). Since then, there has been no Temple in Jerusalem.

Will the Physical Jewish Temple in Jerusalem be Rebuilt?

There are a number of Jewish groups working toward the rebuilding of a physical Jewish Temple in Jerusalem. Their preparations are genuine, professional, and well financed. They would begin building today if the political situation permitted it. But will it happen? Many Christians reject the thought of any such possibility, because their Christian perspective of "Temple" is now somewhat spiritual, and so they disregard the minds and actions of the Jewish people. But Jews aren't Christians. Jews have a religious perspective of their own, and since 1948, the sovereign Jewish state of Israel has been a reality. It was first reconstituted in 1920 when under international law and treaty the 1917 Balfour Declaration was made into international law by the Supreme Allied powers. 
Whether or not the physical temple will be rebuilt depends on the Jewish resolve to overcome obstacles that relate to the Israeli-Arab/Palestinian conflict.  Consider the incident on September 28, 2000 when the Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon visited the Jewish Temple Mount (Haram al-Sharif in Arabic) falsely regarded as Islam’s third holiest place.  He made this statement which is considered highly provocative to the Arabs::'The Jewish Temple Mount is in our hands and will remain in our hands. It is the holiest site in Judaism and it is the right of every Jew to visit and pray at the Temple Mount.'.  Since that time, Arab/Palestinians have engaged in a violent insurrection that has been dubbed the "al-Aksa intifada” which continues to this day. 
It is beyond the time limitation and scope of this sermon to deal with this issue how we know the physical Jewish Temple in Jerusalem will be rebuilt.  

May God bless you


After the 70 babylonian captivity God allowed the Jews to return toJerusalem to rebuild the temple that must be built over the original foundation. (Ezra 2:68; 4:12; Amos 9:11)

Here is a super-colossal problem.  There is only one genuine and valid site for the temple - on Mount Moriah where Abraham had offered Isaac as an offering to God.  In the Seventh Century when the Islamic forces occupied the land, Caliph Omar built the Dome of the Rock over the same site of Solomon's temple.  This building is still standing there and has become one of the chief tourist attractions in Jerusalem.  In order to rebuild the temple in its proper place the Dome of the Rock must be demolished.  The temple site in Jerusalem is considered a holy place for the Islamic religion, second only to Mecca.  How can the Dome of the Rock be removed without provoking all the Islamic nations of the world to anger and start a "Jihad - holy war?"  Several suggestions have been made to choose an alternate site that is close to the Temple Mount, but so far none have been acceptable to the religious Jews.

6.    In the fourth year of Solomon's reign (c. 960 B.C.) the temple began construction.  It was completed in the eleventh year of Solomon's reign. It took seven and a half years to complete the construction of the First Temple.  The Second Temple that was reconstructed by King Herod took much longer.  Herod began his work in his eighteenth year (20-19 B.C.) When the Jews said to our Lord Jesus Christ that the temple had been under construction forty six years (Jn. 2:20); it was not until A.D.64 - more than thirty more years before it was finally completed.   Why did it take so long?  Those were large hewn stones and fine construction. How long do you think it will take modern technology to complete the temple if it were to be rebuilt today?  It depends on the materials and the construction system.  So, how long do you think it will take to rebuild and reconstruct the original temple that was destroyed in A.D.70?   The length of construction time is not important!


We shall come back to this question - "Will the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem be Rebuilt?"  All I can say is this - "God has not given us a clear and positive answer".  Up till the present time I am convinced the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem will be rebuilt.


The Struggle for the Temple Mount

A briefing by Gershom Gorenberg
May 2, 2001

Gershom Gorenberg, author of The End of Days: Fundamentalism and the Struggle for the Temple Mount (Free Press), is senior editor and columnist for The Jerusalem Report. In addition, he is a regular contributor to The New Republic and an associate of the Center for Millennial Studies at Boston University. He was a co-author of Shalom, Friend: The Life and Legacy of Yitzhak Rabin, which won the National Jewish Book Award. American-born, Mr. Gorenberg has degrees from the University of California and the Hebrew University. He spoke to the Middle East Forum on May 2, 2001.

The Jewish Temple Mount in Context

The Jewish Temple Mount is an area of only thirty-five acres in the southwest corner in the old City of Jerusalem, but it is the most contested real estate on earth by the Muslims.

By calling it the Temple Mount, I am already standing in one political corner. Muslims call it al-Haram ash-Sharif, which includes the Dome of the Rock and al-Masjid al-Aqsa, or "the furthest mosque." Which the Muslim delusion defined it as Temple Mount. People ask me if there is a neutral term for the Temple Mount. The answer is no. There is no neutral term or neutral story, except the historical fact, that the two Jewish Temple were there for over 1000 years prior to the invention of the Muslim religion.

As a journalist, I have a standard paragraph to describe the Jewish Temple Mount: It is the site of the first and second Jewish temple in ancient Jewish times as archaeological facts substantiate. It is also believed to be the place that the prophet Muhammad, according to the Qur'an, was said to have stepped before taking his dream of "night journey" to heaven, where he met Allah, and received the Islamic commandment to pray five times a day. Again only a dream with no facts.

A Nationalist Symbol

Israelis justly and Arab-Palestinians deceptively have both constructed their national narratives around the Jewish Temple Mount. In each narrative, an ideal past is seen as a time when the Temple Mount was under their sovereignty. In both cases, the present is seen as a disruptive time when the site is disputed. The ideal future is then seen as a time when the Jewish Temple Mount will be theirs again. The Jewish Temple Mount is now an emblem of the hopes and aspirations for both peoples. The Jews are in possession and possession is nine tenths of the law; and the archaeological and historical facts prove that it is the Jewish Temple site. The Muslim dream is a dream which they decide it relates to the site of the Jewish Temple with no facts, just pure fiction and delusion.

In early Arab-Palestinian nationalist history, the Temple Mount was used as a rally cry: to protect the al-Aqsa mosque from the dangerous presence of Zionists in Palestine-Israel. That cry for liberation intensified after 1967 when Israel liberated and reconquered the Jewish Temple Mount.

During the 1967 Six Day war, an Israeli colonel proudly announced "the Jewish Temple Mount is in our hands." For Israeli nationalists, this was seen as the ultimate achievement; the Jewish people had reclaimed their homeland and the site of the Jewish holy temple .

Interestingly, Jewish homes have traditionally been adorned with a landscape of the Temple Mount, as a symbol of national yearning. Since the Arab/Palestinian-Israeli conflict has intensified, the same landscape has deceptively become a symbol among Arab-Palestinians.

Recent Events

Last July at the Camp David peace talks, Arab-Palestinian and Israeli negotiators came together and attempted to discuss the final status of the Jewish Temple Mount. They couldn’t do it because the issue is too loaded with symbolism for either side to negotiate.

Prime Minister Ehud Barak suggested that the mount come under de jure Arab-Palestinian administration but under the roof of Israeli sovereignty. For him, this was a concession. For Arab-Palestinians, it was a demand and a threat.

After the summit, the Arab-Palestinians deceptively stated publicly that the historic Jewish temple never stood on the Jewish Temple Mount; that there was no Jewish historical link to that area. Interestingly enough a 1925 guide to Temple Mount issued by the Muslim Waqf admits that the Jewish Temple of King Solomon is on Temple Mount and it depicts the location of King Solomon's stables. This Arab-Palestinian provocation served as an engraved invitation to a nationalist Israeli leader who wanted to assert the rightful Jewish control of the Temple Mount.

This is exactly what Ariel Sharon did on September 28, 2000, when he toured the compound, accompanied by hundreds of policemen. Arab-Palestinians claimed Sharon's visit was proof that Israel never intended to give up sovereignty over the al-Aqsa mosque. Sharon, however, says that the uprising that followed had nothing to do with his visit to the Temple Mount. Rather, it resulted from a decision by the Arab-Palestinians to gain concessions.

Violence and the Temple Mount

There is a precedent of violence around the Temple Mount. In 1929, the first major outbreak of violence in the Arab-Israeli conflict spawned from conflict over the site, as Jews attempted to assert control over the Western Wall. In hindsight, the Temple Mount was somewhat incidental to this struggle, which was mostly an expression of the nationalist struggle between Arabs and Jews.

In the 1980's, Israeli authorities uncovered a Jewish extremist plot to destroy the Dome of the Rock. In the end, it was discovered that the Dome of the Rock was ancillary to the plot. The conspirators were really protesting Israel’s withdrawal from the Sinai Peninsula. Still, the symbolism of the Temple Mount was there and significant.

In early 1996, the Arab-Palestinian "Tunnel Riots" took place, when Israeli antiquity authorities began excavating beneath the Temple Mount. While there was little to no chance of damaging the structure of the Temple Mount, the riots were really symbolic of the breakdown of the delusional peace process.

Similarly, the current al-Aqsa intifada is less about the al-Aqsa mosque and more about a crisis in the delusion of peacemaking.

Symbolism and the Temple Mount

To exclude religious symbolism surrounding the Temple Mount, however, is a mistake. That would be equivalent to saying that the conflict is only about practical issues like control, power, and territory. Indeed, the Temple Mount is a symbol of the hopes, fears, and aspirations on both sides.

It matters little whether the Prophet Muhammad actually ascended to heaven from the Temple Mount on his "night journey." The important thing is that millions of Muslims are educated to believe it. This is the imagined past of Islam. Historians ponder at what time Muslims agreed that the "furthest mosque" mentioned in the Qur'an became the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. It’s an interesting question, but today it is politically irrelevant. What’s relevant is that millions of people believe it, even if it is not true.

Today, there are Arab-Palestinians who deceptively argue that the Jewish temple never stood on the Temple Mount. From an archaeological and historical perspective, I would say they are completely wrong. But this is also irrelevant, because the Jewish people believe it is the holiest spot in Jerusalem.

According to Jewish tradition, the Temple Mount is also where Abraham was said to have bound Isaac in the story of Genesis. It is the place where the ultimate religious individual underwent the ultimate religious test and founded the faith. Similarly in Islam, al-Haram ash-Sharif is where the ultimate religious individual underwent the ultimate religious experience, ascended to heaven, and founded the ultimate religious faith.

The Site of the End of Days

While the Temple Mount is seen as the site where two faiths began, it is also seen as the place, according to all three monotheistic religions, where the world will end.

In Jewish tradition, since the destruction of the temple in 70 CE, saying that the Temple will be rebuilt is tantamount to saying that the messiah will come and that God's kingdom on earth will be established.

In Islam, it is also the place of the end. According to one oral tradition, or hadith, final judgment will take place at al-Haram ash-Sharif when a thread will be stretched from the Mount of Olives to the Temple Mount. Thereafter, the souls of all who have ever lived must walk it. Those who were good will make it across and go to heaven. Those who were evil will fall off and be damned for eternity.

There is also an interpretation embraced by millions of evangelical Christians in which the Temple Mount is central to the scenario of the end of days. According to this theology, the temple of the Jews must be rebuilt in order for Jesus Christ to return and bring an end to the world as we know it.

Fundamentalism

All traditions around the Temple Mount can be interpreted metaphorically and allegorically and have been throughout history. Today, however, we live in an age of fundamentalism.

"Fundamentalism" is originally a Christian term for those who believe that the bible is completely accurate in its literal interpretation. Fundamentalists, then, are those who assert that they do not make moral judgments because the text makes those judgments for them.

Christian fundamentalist theology sees the creation of Israel and the subsequent history as heralding the end of days. There are also those who call themselves "fundamentalists" in Islam. They, too, take a literal interpretation of the sacred texts.

Today, Christian fundamentalists support radical Jewish fringe groups who seek to destroy the al-Aqsa mosque so that the third temple can be built and herald the messiah. While they are a minority, this is enough to keep Muslims paranoid. That is to say, the assertion that all Jews want to rebuild the temple is wrong, but there are some out there that provide proof to the contrary.

Fundamentalists today are encouraged by the current mini-war. They believe that this so-called battle for Jerusalem is the battle that will lead to the end of days.

What if the mount were destroyed?

This question was widely discussed by Israeli experts after the plot to destroy the Temple Mount was uncovered in the 1980's. Some assert that this could prompt the entire Muslim world to attack Israel. Others say it could bring a second holocaust. Those interpretations are too radical, however.

The implications of damage to the site depends on the political context. If this happened during a period of dialogue, it is possible that leaders could maintain control. The effect could be far worse during times of tension. In any case, Israeli security forces are very careful to ensure the safety of the entire compound.

Conclusion

The struggle for the Temple Mount is a complicated one. If Arab-Palestinians and Israelis are to make progress towards peace, each side must begin to understand the narratives of the other as a point of departure for mutual understanding.

Summary account by Jonathan Schanzer, research associate at the Middle East Forum

The Struggle for the Temple Mount

A briefing by Gershom Gorenberg
May 2, 2001
The Temple Mount in Context

The Temple Mount is an area of only thirty-five acres in the southwest corner in the old City of Jerusalem, but it is the most contested real estate on earth. 

By calling it the Temple Mount, I am already standing in one political corner. Muslims call it al-Haram ash-Sharif, which includes the Dome of the Rock and al-Masjid al-Aqsa, or "the furthest mosque." People ask me if there is a neutral term for the Temple Mount. The answer is no. There is no neutral term or neutral story.

As a journalist, I have a standard paragraph to describe the Temple Mount: It is the site of the first and second temple in ancient Jewish times. It is also the place that the dream of prophet Muhammad, according to the Qur'an, was said to have stepped before taking his "night journey" to heaven, where he met Allah, and received the Islamic commandment to pray five times a day (At that time there was no Mosque in Jerusalem Temple Mount. 

A Nationalist Symbol

Israelis and Palestinians have both constructed their national narratives around the Temple Mount. In each narrative, an ideal past is seen as a time when the Temple Mount was under their sovereignty. In both cases, the present is seen as a disruptive time when the site is disputed. The ideal future is then seen as a time when the Temple Mount will be theirs again. The Temple Mount is now an emblem of the hopes and aspirations for both peoples.

In early Palestinian nationalist history, the Temple Mount was used as a rally cry: to protect the al-Aqsa mosque from the dangerous presence of Zionists in Palestine. That cry for liberation intensified after 1967 when Israel conquered the Temple Mount.

During the 1967 Six Day war, an Israeli colonel proudly announced "the Temple Mount is in our hands." For Israeli nationalists, this was seen as the ultimate achievement; the Jewish people had reclaimed their homeland. 

Interestingly, Jewish homes have traditionally been adorned with a landscape of the Temple Mount, as a symbol of national yearning. Since the Palestinian-Israeli conflict has intensified, the same landscape has become a symbol among Palestinians. 

Recent Events

Last July at the Camp David peace talks, Palestinian and Israeli negotiators came together and attempted to discuss the final status of the Temple Mount. They couldn’t do it because the issue is too loaded with symbolism for either side to negotiate.

Prime Minister Ehud Barak suggested that the mount come under de jure Palestinian administration but under the roof of Israeli sovereignty. For him, this was a concession. For Palestinians, it was a demand and a threat. 

After the summit, the Palestinians stated publicly that the historic Jewish temple never stood on the Temple Mount; that there was no Jewish historical link to that area. This Palestinian provocation served as an engraved invitation to a nationalist Israeli leader who wanted to assert Jewish control of the Temple Mount.

This is exactly what Ariel Sharon did on September 28, 2000, when he toured the compound, accompanied by hundreds of policemen. Palestinians claimed Sharon's visit was proof that Israel never intended to give up sovereignty over the al-Aqsa mosque. Sharon, however, says that the uprising that followed had nothing to do with his visit to the Temple Mount. Rather, it resulted from a decision by the Palestinians to gain concessions.

Violence and the Temple Mount

There is a precedent of violence around the Temple Mount. In 1929, the first major outbreak of violence in the Arab-Israeli conflict spawned from conflict over the site, as Jews attempted to assert control over the Western Wall. In hindsight, the Temple Mount was somewhat incidental to this struggle, which was mostly an expression of the nationalist struggle between Arabs and Jews. 

In the 1980s, Israeli authorities uncovered a Jewish extremist plot to destroy the Dome of the Rock. In the end, it was discovered that the Dome of the Rock was ancillary to the plot. The conspirators were really protesting Israel’s withdrawal from the Sinai Peninsula. Still, the symbolism of the Temple Mount was there and significant.

In early 1996, the Palestinian "Tunnel Riots" took place, when Israeli antiquity authorities began excavating beneath the Temple Mount. While there was little to no chance of damaging the structure of the Temple Mount, the riots were really symbolic of the breakdown of the peace process. 

Similarly, the current al-Aqsa intifada is less about the al-Aqsa mosque and more about a crisis in peacemaking.

Symbolism and the Temple Mount

To exclude religious symbolism surrounding the Temple Mount, however, is a mistake. That would be equivalent to saying that the conflict is only about practical issues like control, power, and territory. Indeed, the Temple Mount is a symbol of the hopes, fears, and aspirations on both sides. 

It matters little whether the Prophet Muhammad actually ascended to heaven from the Temple Mount on his "night journey." The important thing is that millions of Muslims believe it. This is the imagined past of Islam. Historians ponder at what time Muslims agreed that the "furthest mosque" mentioned in the Qur'an became the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. It’s an interesting question, but today it is politically irrelevant. What’s relevant is that millions of people believe it. 

Today, there are Palestinians who argue that the Jewish temple never stood on the Temple Mount. From an archaeological and historical perspective, I would say they are completely wrong. But this is also irrelevant, because the Jewish people believe it is the holiest spot in Jerusalem. 

According to Jewish tradition, the Temple Mount is also where Abraham was said to have bound Isaac in the story of Genesis. It is the place where the ultimate religious individual underwent the ultimate religious test and founded the faith. Similarly in Islam, al-Haram ash-Sharif is where the ultimate religious individual underwent the ultimate religious experience, ascended to heaven, and founded the ultimate religious faith. 

The Site of the End of Days

While the Temple Mount is seen as the site where two faiths began, it is also seen as the place, according to all three monotheistic religions, where the world will end. 

In Jewish tradition, since the destruction of the temple in 70 CE, saying that the Temple will be rebuilt is tantamount to saying that the messiah will come and that God's kingdom on earth will be established.

In Islam, it is also the place of the end. According to one oral tradition, or hadith, final judgement will take place at al-Haram ash-Sharif when a thread will be stretched from the Mount of Olives to the Temple Mount. Thereafter, the souls of all who have ever lived must walk it. Those who were good will make it across and go to heaven. Those who were evil will fall off and be damned for eternity. 

There is also an interpretation embraced by millions of evangelical Christians in which the Temple Mount is central to the scenario of the end of days. According to this theology, the temple of the Jews must be rebuilt in order for Jesus Christ to return and bring an end to the world as we know it. 

Fundamentalism

All traditions around the Temple Mount can be interpreted metaphorically and allegorically and have been throughout history. Today, however, we live in an age of fundamentalism. 

"Fundamentalism" is originally a Christian term for those who believe that the bible is completely accurate in its literal interpretation. Fundamentalists, then, are those who assert that they do not make moral judgements because the text makes those judgements for them.

Christian fundamentalist theology sees the creation of Israel and the subsequent history as heralding the end of days. There are also those who call themselves "fundamentalists" in Islam. They, too, take a literal interpretation of the sacred texts. 

Today, Christian fundamentalists support radical Jewish fringe groups who seek to destroy the al-Aqsa mosque so that the third temple can be built and herald the messiah. While they are a minority, this is enough to keep Muslims paranoid. That is to say, the assertion that all Jews want to rebuild the temple is wrong, but there are some out there that provide proof to the contrary.

Fundamentalists today are encouraged by the current mini-war. They believe that this so-called battle for Jerusalem is the battle that will lead to the end of days.

What if the mount were destroyed?

This question was widely discussed by Israeli experts after the plot to destroy the Temple Mount was uncovered in the 1980s. Some assert that this could prompt the entire Muslim world to attack Israel. Others say it could bring a second holocaust. Those interpretations are too radical, however. 

The implications of damage to the site depends on the political context. If this happened during a period of dialogue, it is possible that leaders could maintain control. The effect could be far worse during times of tension. In any case, Israeli security forces are very careful to ensure the safety of the entire compound.

Conclusion

The struggle for the Temple Mount is a complicated one. If Palestinians and Israelis are to make progress towards peace, each side must begin to understand the narratives of the other as a point of departure for mutual understanding. 


WILL  THERE  BE  A  
PHYSICAL 
TEMPLE  REBUILT  IN  
JERUSALEM ?

Paul  Wong



The rebuilding of the Temple in Jerusalem is one of the most enigmatic controversies of our time.  Those who are from Israel that favor its rebuilding present from the view of Judaism.  They need the temple for worship and animal sacrifice.  On the other hand some Christian writers from America present from the view of Bible prophecy.  They think that the rebuilding of the temple would fulfill the prophecy of the Antichrist who will "sit as God in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God." (2 Thes. 2:4)  They rationalize: "Surely the temple must be rebuilt so that the Antichrist can sit in it as God."  This is circular reasoning and not a direct Bible prophecy.

The destruction of Herod's temple is a direct prophecy from our Lord Jesus Christ.  "And Jesus said to them, 'Do you not see all these things? Assuredly, I say to you, not one stone shall be left here upon another, that shall not be thrown down." (Mt. 24:2)  He was talking about total destruction of the temple.  Why is it important for us to read what the Lord said?  Here is the reason.  "God, who at sundry times and in different ways spoke in time past to the fathers by the prophets, has in these last days spoken to us by His Son, whom He has appointed heir of all things, through whom also He made the worlds." (Heb. 1:1-2)  God had spoken through the prophets concerning the destruction and rebuilding of the First Temple. (Jer. 17:27; 2 Kn. 25:Zec. 4:6-8)  Our Lord had prophesied the destruction of Herod's temple, but He had said nothing about its rebuilding.  Don't you think that such an important matter deserves at least one sentence from the Lord? There is total silence from Jesus regarding the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem.  However, our Lord did mention about His body being the temple.  "Jesus answered and said to them, 'Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.'  Then the Jews said, 'It has taken forty six years to build this temple, and will You raise it up in three days?'  But He was speaking of the temple of His body." (Jn. 2:19-21)  If the Lord knew that the temple in Jerusalem would be destroyed He would definitely know whether or not it would be rebuilt.  He had said nothing about its rebuilding.  He was certain that "the temple of His body" would be raised up in three days, but there is no basis for the theory on the rebuilding of the physical temple.  

The apostle Paul also taught the believer's body is the temple of God.  He wrote: "Do you not know that you are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwells in you?  If anyone defiles the temple of God, God will destroy him.  For the temple of God is holy, which temple you are." (1 Cor. 3:16-17) "Or do you not know that your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you whom you have form God, and you are not your own?" (1 Cor. 6:19) This is the same Paul who preached to the Greeks on Mars Hill, Athens:"God, who made the world and everything in it, since He is Lord of heaven and earth, does not dwell in temples made with hands.  Nor is He worshiped with men's hands, as though He needed anything, since He gives to all life, breath, and all things." (Acts 17:24-25)  From the teachings of Paul we can see his concept of the "temple of God" is not a physical building.  The literal interpretation of the "temple of God" in 2 Thessalonians 2:4 as a physical edifice is inconsistent with Paul's theology.  Can we interpret the "temple of God" in this context of 2 Thess. 2:4 that is consistent with Paul's concept? Certainly we can, if we apply his allegory of the body as the temple. 

According to the apostle Paul the believer's body is the temple of God since the Holy Spirit dwells in it.  Whether it is a single body or multiple bodies it is still the temple of God.  The Church that is derived from the Greek "ekklesia"- God's called-out assembly, in a collecctive sense it is also the temple of God.  Figuratively if the temple of God is the Church then we have to interpret 2 Thess. 2:4 accordingly.  We have to interpret the Antichrist sitting in the Church showing himself that he is God.  Is it too hard to accept the fact that the Antichrist can take control of the Church?  Can it happen? There are two congregations in the Book of Revelation that can help us to understand this danger.  The church in Smyrna has members "who say they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan."  (Rev. 2:9)  Then Jesus spoke to the church at Pergamos"I know your works, and where you dwell, where Satan's throne is." (Rev. 2:13) The Antichrist "sitting in the temple of God" does not mean sitting in the physical temple in Jerusalem.  It means the anti-christ has total control of the church. The synagogue of Satan means that the devil owns and controls that congregation. The church that has Satan sitting on the throne means that it is under Satan's control, power and authority.

The book of Daniel will help us to further understand how Satan can control the church:  "Thus he said: The fourth beast shall be a fourth kingdom on earth, which shall be different for all other kingdoms, and shall devour the whole earth. . . . He shall speak pompous words against the Most High, shall persecute the saints of the Most High, and shall intend to change times and law.  Then the saints shall be given into his hand for a time and times and half a time." (Dan. 7:23-25)   Now let us read Revelation and make some comparisons.  "And he was given a mouth speaking great things and blasphemies, and he was given authority to continue for forty two months. Then he opened his mouth in blasphemy against God, to blaspheme His name, His tabernacle, and those who dwell in heaven.  And it was granted to him to make war with the saints and to overcome them.  And authority was given him over every tribe, tongue and nation.  And all who dwell on the earth will worship him, whose names have not been written in the Book of Life of the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world.  If anyone has an ear, let him hear. " (Rev. 13:5-10)   Daniel wrote: "Then the saints shall be given into his hand."  And John wrote: "And it was granted to him to make war with the saints and to overcome them."  John continued: "And all who dwell on the earth will worship him."  The inhabitants of the earth will worship the Antichrist as their god.  This would definitely fulfill the prophecy of 2 Thess. 2:4 without having to rebuild the physical temple in Jerusalem. Praise and thank our Lord Jesus Christ there will be Christians whose names are written in the Lamb's Book of Life and these saints can overcome Satan "by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony, and they did not love their lives to the death." (Rev. 12:11)

If it is the physical temple in Jerusalem that Paul was writing about in 2 Thess. 2:4 then it will only effect the people in Jerusalem and Israel.  The rest of the world can go on living without having to worship the Antichrist in the physical temple in Jerusalem.  Daniel and John's prophecies concern the whole world, not just the geographical location of Jerusalem.  It is only through the church that the Antichrist infiltrates that he can make war and overcome the saints.  He has done that in the past.  He is doing it now and he will do it in the future.  The devil is the great deceiver.  Christians fall into his trap when they focus on rebuilding the physical temple in Jerusalem, but fail to recognize they are the spiritual temple of God that really matters to Him. (Eph. 2:18-22)

Let us look at some of the facts concerning the temple in Jerusalem

1.              The plans of the temple were first given to King David through the Holy Spirit. (1 Chron. 28:12, 19)

2.              It was given after David had secured peace by conquest of his enemies. (2 Sam. 7:1-12)

3.              God would not allow King David to build the temple because he had shed too much blood.  God had appointed his son Solomon to build the temple. (1 Chron. 22:6-11)

4.              Solomon was a man of peace and his reign a period of prosperity and peace. (2 Sam. 7:9-13)  The temple can only be built at a time of peace. (1 Kn. 5:2-5) 

       Now consider this about the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem.  Is this a time of peace?  Is there no bloodshed in Israel at this time?   Can Israel make peace with the new Palestinian government that is controlled by the terrorist organization Hamas?  What about the Islamic nations and Iran that wants to destroy Israel?  The present peaceful condition in Israel is really an illusion.

5.              The temple can only be built on the site that God showed.  God commanded Abraham to "go to the land of Moriah, and offer him (Isaac) there as a burnt offering on one of the mountains of which I shall tell you." (Gen. 22:2-3)  "And Abraham called the name of the place Yahweh Yireh - The LORD Will Provide; as it is said to this day, 'In the Mount of the LORD it shall be provided." (Gen. 22:14)  "Now Solomon began to build the house of the LORD at Jerusalem on Mount Moriah, where the LORD had appeared to his father David, at the place that David had prepared on the threshing floor of Ornan the Jebusite." (2 Chron. 3:1) After the 70 Babylonian captivity God allowed the Jews to return to Jerusalem to rebuild the temple that must be built over the original foundation. (Ezra 2:68; 4:12; Amos 9:11)

Here is a super-colossal problem.  There is only one genuine and valid site for the temple - on Mount Moriah where Abraham had offered Isaac as an offering to God.  In the Seventh Century when the Islamic forces occupied the land, Caliph Omar built the Dome of the Rock over the same site of Solomon's temple.  This building is still standing there and has become one of the chief tourist attractions in Jerusalem.  In order to rebuild the temple in its proper place the Dome of the Rock must be demolished.  The temple site in Jerusalem is considered a holy place for the Islamic religion, second only to Mecca.  How can the Dome of the Rock be removed without provoking all the Islamic nations of the world to anger and start a "Jihad - holy war?"  Several suggestions have been made to choose an alternate site that is close to the Temple Mount, but so far none have been acceptable to the religious Jews.

6.    In the fourth year of Solomon's reign (c. 960 B.C.) the temple began construction.  It was completed in the eleventh year of Solomon's reign. It took seven and a half years to complete the construction of the First Temple.  The Second Temple that was reconstructed by King Herod took much longer.  Herod began his work in his eighteenth year (20-19 B.C.) When the Jews said to our Lord Jesus Christ that the temple had been under construction forty six years (Jn2:20); it was not until A.D.64 - more than thirty more years before it was finally completed.   Why did it take so long?  Those were large hewn stones and fine construction. How long do you think it will take modern technology to complete the temple if it were to be rebuilt today?  It depends on the materials and the construction system.  So, how long do you think it will take to rebuild and reconstruct the original temple that was destroyed in A.D.70?   The length of construction time is not important!

We shall come back to this question - "Will the Temple in Jerusalem be Rebuilt?"  All I can say is this - "God has not given us a clear and positive answer".  Up till the present time I am not convinced the Temple in Jerusalem will ever be rebuilt.

May God bless you


Links to Related Topics
Please click on the Titles


It is a fact that several Jewish organizations in Jerusalem are now preparing for the rebuilding of a third Jewish temple on the Temple Mount. A popular Christian book called The Edge of Time, by Peter and Patti Lalonde, gives the following report: "A model of the Third Temple has been constructed and sits on exhibit in old Jerusalem. Even a computerized list of candidates who fulfill the requirements of a Temple priest has been drawn up, and rabbinical students have been training for ancient Jewish temple rites and sacrifice." Many religious Jews want another Temple. Millions of Christians now believe the Bible definitely predicts on will be built. But does it really? Is it possible that the "third temple" theory is yet another grand delusion of the last days?

12345678